Air purifier vs dehumidifier: Which is the better choice?

Dust, mould, and other indoor air pollutants are common household problems, especially if you live in the humid coastal regions of Australia. Fortunately, you can help eliminate these pollutants using an air purifier or humidifier. 

But which of these two devices can help address your specific air quality concerns at home more effectively? Find out the answers here as we explore their differences in this air purifier vs dehumidifier guide. 

What is an air purifier?

An air purifier removes pollen, dust, dander and other indoor air pollutants through filtration, helping keep indoor air clean. 

Most air purifiers come with High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filters composed of dense web fibres that trap dust and other airborne pollutants. Other models have activated carbon filters to capture gases and odours (such as smoke and chemical vapours) and Ultraviolet (UV) light to kill airborne bacteria and viruses.

What is a dehumidifier? 

A dehumidifier helps control humidity by pulling moist air from the room through a fan and using refrigerated coils to extract water vapour from the air. This helps adjust the room temperature to a more comfortable level while eliminating musty odours and improving indoor air quality.

Some dehumidifiers also have a HEPA filter, like air purifiers. They give the best of both worlds as they regulate humidity while filtering out air pollutants. 

One downside of dehumidifiers is the amount of time it takes to dry out a room completely. So, how long do dehumidifiers take to work? For everyday use, 6 to 12 hrs is enough to control moisture, but water-damaged rooms typically need at least 24 to 72 hours. This can take longer, depending on the size and type of dehumidifier and the humidity level of a room.

Air dehumidifier vs air purifier: What are their key differences?

From the definitions alone, it’s clear that an air purifier is not the same as a dehumidifier. This comparison guide further explores each device’s unique functionalities to address various air quality concerns in your home properly.

In terms of functionality

You’ll have to look into how each device functions to understand the difference between dehumidifiers and air purifiers. 

As mentioned, air purifiers help keep indoor air clean using various specialised filters. This is how it works: the fans help draw the air inside the device and pass through a series of filters, capturing the pollutants. After that, clean air is released back into the room. 

A dehumidifier also uses a fan to pull in the air, but instead of filtering pollutants, it removes water vapour in the air using cold refrigerated coils. This causes the water vapour to condense and drip on the water tank inside the dehumidifier, making the air drier. Lastly, dry air passes through warm coils, returning warm, comfortable air to the room. 

In terms of humidity control

Humidity control is essential if your house has poor ventilation, feels uncomfortably hot, or has damp walls and floors due to water leaks or a flood. These situations can trigger allergic reactions like asthma, and using a dehumidifier can help mitigate these humidity problems. 

Dehumidifiers can control the Relative Humidity (RH) level (or the amount of water vapour in the air) to a comfortable and healthy humidity level of 40% to 60% RH. Because of this, it is helpful to use dehumidifiers in basements, kitchens, and bathrooms, especially if these places have been infected with mould and mildew.

Conversely, air purifiers don’t directly impact humidity levels. They can only help clean the air rather than adjust its moisture content.

In terms of indoor air quality improvement

Do air purifiers help with dust? Yes, air purifiers help eliminate dust, dirt, and other airborne contaminants. In fact, the HEPA filter in air purifiers filters 99.97% of airborne particles that are 0.3 micrometres wide, including dust particles.

For homeowners still using gas stoves, air purifiers can also be extra helpful. Remember that gas stoves release harmful pollutants such as carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide, so aside from keeping the windows open while cooking, keep the air purifier running to help eliminate smoke and dangerous gases in the kitchen.

Meanwhile, dehumidifiers help improve indoor air quality by controlling moisture. Excessive moisture can cause mould to grow. If left untreated, microbial volatile compounds (VOCs) in mould can produce smelly, musty odours. So, when cleaning apartments and houses, consider using a dehumidifier to control odours.

In terms of energy efficiency

Air purifiers can help save more energy, especially those models with an automatic adjustment feature. This allows you to optimise their performance, reducing unnecessary usage. 

On the contrary, many dehumidifiers are less energy-efficient than purifiers because the process of condensing moisture in the air takes hours to complete. Luckily, many modern dehumidifiers now have energy-efficient settings. 

In terms of noise control

Most dehumidifiers can be very noisy because of their built-in compressor and fan. But the good news is that newer dehumidifier models now have noise-reduction features such as rubber dampening pads and noise-reducing insulation.

On the flip side, air purifiers have better noise control than dehumidifiers, with most advanced models having silent operation modes. Consider also looking into air purifiers with ionisation or UV light technologies because they operate much more quietly than regular air purifiers.

In terms of cost

The costs of owning both an air purifier and dehumidifier depend on their size and type, specific features such as an automatic adjustment feature and noise control, daily energy use, maintenance, and more.

But to give you an idea, dehumidifiers are generally more affordable with effective cost-effective models priced at under $100. As for air purifiers, the price ranges at $350 to $500, or sometimes more. 

When it comes to daily energy consumption and operational costs, the figures may vary because both factors depend on the wattage of an air purifier and dehumidifier. However, air purifiers can incur more maintenance costs since you have to replace the filters every six months to ensure their effectiveness. 

Achieve a cleaner indoor environment with Airtasker

Using an air purifier or dehumidifier is only one of the many ways you can maintain a clean indoor environment. You must still do periodic deep cleaning to eliminate viruses and bacteria on surfaces, further improving indoor air quality. 

Why not seek help from cleaning experts at Airtasker? They are equipped with the knowledge and skill and have tools to keep the air indoors clean and healthy.