Shutters vs blinds: Which is right for you?

Large glass windows are standard in Australian homes to emphasise the connection between indoor and outdoor spaces. Although these windows help add more natural light, they can make homes feel hot and humid inside, especially in some parts of Australia with warmer temperatures. This is why window treatments such as shutters and blinds are added to make living rooms more comfortable to lounge around. 

However, keep in mind that shutters vs blinds differ in construction and design, so you must choose carefully between these two to ensure they perfectly fit your home. 

What are shutters?

Shutters are permanent window treatments fitted to the sides of the windows. You can either install them inside or outside the house to add a window covering. Some homeowners even combine interior and exterior shutters in their windows for better insulation. 

Traditional shutters are made of narrow wooden louvres or slats that can be opened and closed to control light and improve home ventilation. Today, you can find window shutters with a modern design, like plantation shutters. They typically are made from faux wood and PVC and have larger louvres than the traditional ones. 

One disadvantage of installing shutters for windows is that the louvres can obstruct some of the views on the windows even if you completely open them. Plus, replacing shutters would be difficult and more expensive due to their permanent installation design. 

What are blinds?

Blinds are window treatments made of horizontal or vertical slats with cords holding these slats together. Like shutters, blinds are made from various materials such as solid wood, faux wood, aluminium, and fabric. However, blinds have a more flexible design than shutters because you may tilt, raise, or lower them to increase your privacy and control light. 

In addition, blinds are versatile window treatments suitable for many contemporary and modern homes.  They usually come in many styles and designs, including:

• Venetian blinds with classic horizontal slats 

• Louvred blinds with vertical slats

• Cellular blinds with honeycomb-styled shades

• Smart blinds or remote-controlled blinds with motorised slats

Blinds also have a fair share of disadvantages. Their slats are not as durable as shutters, so be careful when cleaning the slats of blinds. 

Blinds vs shutters: Which adds more value to your home?

Whether you are planning on a complete house renovation or a simple home upgrade, choosing the right window treatment is vital in elevating your home’s functionality and aesthetic value. 

This comparison guide explores the distinct features and functions of the two most popular window treatments, blinds and shutters, to help you decide which would be more suitable for your windows. 

In terms of light and privacy control

If you’ve decided already to go with shutters, particularly the plantation shutters, one lingering question would be, do they block out light? Yes, but not completely. Although plantation shutters have tilted louvres that help control natural light, small streams of light can still escape through the gaps in between these tilted louvres. 

Moreover, some modern plantation shutters have flexible louvres. Double-hung shutters, in particular, can give you more privacy while allowing more natural light in the house, as they consist of separate lower and upper sections.

Meanwhile, window blinds, like Venetian blinds, provide excellent light control because their slats are adjustable. However, other types of blinds, like Roman blinds, offer less privacy. You’ll have to completely roll them up or down, giving you less flexibility in controlling light and privacy in your home. 

In terms of energy efficiency

Do shutters keep heat in? Yes, because they completely enclose a window frame, helping resist heat transfer to keep homes cool. Moreover, real wood shutters are thermally dynamic, meaning they reflect the cold outside air. This improves insulation, helping you save more energy.

Other types of shutters, like faux wood shutters, also have a hollow core made of vinyl or PVC. This hollow core creates air pockets that help block or resist heat transfer. 

On the other hand, blinds are less superior in terms of energy efficiency. Unlike shutters, you only have to install them at the topmost part of the window frame. This allows heat to escape or penetrate through the gaps between slats. 

In terms of durability

Shutters are more durable in general. With proper care and maintenance, these window treatments can last long, especially faux wood shutters. And since they’re fitted securely inside or outside the window recess (the little nook in the wall where the window is installed), they’re less likely to get damaged.

Meanwhile, the durability of the blinds depends on the material they’re made from. Faux wood and metal blinds are generally more durable than other types of blinds. However, window blinds made of solid wood are less durable than most shutters because their slats are thinner, so they can easily bend and break.

Another thing is that blinds have cords and pulleys that can wear out quickly with repeated use. Fortunately, a professional can still repair your blinds if someone accidentally pulls on the cord too hard and breaks the slats.

In terms of maintenance

Between plantation shutters vs blinds, shutters are easier to clean or maintain due to having a more durable structure and less intricate design. Plus, you only have to occasionally wipe plantation shutters with a damp cloth because they usually don’t collect as much dust, unlike blinds. 

On the other hand, cleaning vertical wooden blinds is a little more complicated since they can be fragile. A soft cloth or duster is necessary to prevent the slats from breaking while wiping the dust off. You must also be extra careful when cleaning Venetian blinds, especially those made from light materials such as aluminium and vinyl, because they’re prone to damage. 

In terms of aesthetic appeal

Both window treatments come in many styles, colours, patterns, and sizes, making them both ideal for bespoke windows. However, blinds are more suitable for modernised homes. Venetian and Roman fabric blinds, in particular, are decorative blinds ideal for modern minimalist spaces because of their clean and uncluttered look.

Meanwhile, for a more classic and traditional look, choose DIY shutters. These window treatments have a timeless charm with their solid panels, tilted louvres, and picture-framed design. If this seems too old-fashioned, you may opt for external window shutters with larger louvres for a cleaner and more streamlined look. 

In terms of the assembly process

Assembling blinds is slightly more manageable because they have a simple design and come in standardised sizes. However, you may still need professional help, especially when fitting window curtain blinds. Having an expert do the job ensures they’re securely attached to your windows, preventing the blinds from falling quickly when pets and kids accidentally pull the cord.

Meanwhile, assembling and installing shutters is more difficult because they require precise measurements to fit them securely on your windows. Plus, it is more hassle and time-consuming since they typically require more tools and steps. 

Take the hassle out of your shutters or blinds assembly with Airtasker

While DIY blinds and shutters might seem like a fun project you can do with your family, having an expert help install them is still much better. Not only can they help you securely fit your blinds and shutters, but they can also save you from costly damages.

At Airtasker, you can find many assembly experts who can help you install your window treatments. Just post a task indicating the specific services you need and your budget, and then wait for Taskers to send quotes and proposals.