Quartz vs. granite countertops: Which is the better choice?

Renovating your kitchen is a big investment, and choosing the wrong countertop can lead to regrets down the line. Quartz and granite both have their advantages, but making the right choice depends on your specific needs.

This guide explores the key differences between quartz vs. granite countertops, discussing common concerns about cost, durability, and maintenance, so you can avoid pitfalls and choose the right countertop with confidence.

What is a quartz countertop? 

A sleek quartz countertop adds elegance and durability to this modern kitchen design (Source: iStock)

A quartz countertop is an engineered type of countertop created by binding natural quartz crystals with resin, pigments, and sometimes small amounts of recycled glass or metallic flecks. This process produces a versatile material that mimics the appearance of natural stone while offering enhanced durability and uniformity.

One of the standout features of quartz is its non-porous nature, making it highly resistant to stains, scratches, and bacteria. This quality makes quartz a practical choice for busy households or families with young children. 

What is a granite countertop? 

Granite countertops bring timeless beauty and durability to kitchens, showcasing unique natural patterns that elevate any space (Source: iStock)

Granite countertops are made from solid slabs of natural stone, giving each piece a unique appearance. They’re preferred by most homeowners due to their stunning, one-of-a-kind patterns and earthy tones that bring a sense of timeless elegance to kitchens.

However, being a natural material, granite is porous, which means it needs regular sealing to maintain its resistance to stains and moisture. While it may require a bit more upkeep, many homeowners find its natural charm and durability worth the effort.

Granite vs. quartz countertops: Which fits your kitchen better?

If you’re deciding between granite and quartz, it’s essential to weigh several factors, including appearance, durability, maintenance, and cost. Here’s, let’s delve deeper into the difference between quartz and granite countertops.

In terms of appearance

Granite countertops offer stunning natural patterns that make each piece unique, adding a distinctive charm to any kitchen design (Source: Stock)

Quartz and granite both offer stunning options for homeowners exploring different kitchen countertop ideas. Granite countertop has a unique and natural look, with every slab featuring its own distinctive veining and textures. The unique beauty of this countertop makes it perfect for kitchens aiming for a bespoke, luxurious feel.

Quartz countertop, on the other hand, offers more consistency in color and pattern, thanks to its engineered nature. It’s available in a broader range of colors, from bold, striking tones to subtle, elegant hues, making it ideal for modern kitchens that require a uniform aesthetic.

In terms of heat resistance 

When evaluating kitchen ideas, think about how heat-resistant countertops like granite or quartz can suit your cooking style. 

Granite countertops are highly heat-resistant due to their natural composition, making them an excellent choice for handling hot pans and pots directly on the surface without the risk of damage. 

Meanwhile, quartz countertops are less resistant to heat because they contain resin, which can be damaged by high temperatures. Placing hot cookware directly on a quartz countertop can lead to discoloration or warping. For this reason, it’s highly recommended to use heat pads or trivets when using hot cookware to protect the surface.

In terms of durability

Quartz countertops are renowned for their durability, withstanding chipping or cracking, while maintaining their polished appearance (Source: Stock)

Both quartz and granite countertops are highly durable, but their resistance to scratches and chipping differs. Quartz countertops are engineered with resin, which makes them more flexible and less prone to chipping or cracking. It also offers superior scratch resistance, making it ideal for busy kitchens.

Granite is harder but more brittle, meaning it’s slightly more susceptible to chipping under heavy impact. However, it remains an incredibly tough material that can withstand daily wear and tear.

In terms of cleaning and maintenance

When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, a quartz countertop stands out for its exceptional stain resistance. A quartz countertop made of engineered quartz is non-porous, preventing liquids and spills from seeping in and making it easy to clean with just soapy water or a mild cleaning solution.

Granite countertops are porous, requiring regular sealing to maintain their resistance to stains and prevent moisture absorption. Without proper sealing, substances like oil or wine can leave marks on granite surfaces.

In terms of cost

Both quartz and granite countertops come in a variety of styles and price points, offering options to suit different budgets and preferences (Source: iStock)

While many wonder if quartz is cheaper than granite, the two are often comparable in price. 

Quartz countertops cost around $50 to $100 per square foot for supply and installation. The replacement cost for quartz countertops is approximately $50–$150 per square foot. One of the best things about quartz is that it requires no sealing or special treatments, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.

Granite countertops are slightly more expensive on average, at $60 to $100 per square foot, depending on the type and quality. The replacement cost for granite countertops is approximately $60–$135 per square foot. Additionally, ongoing maintenance, such as regular sealing, is required to maintain its durability and stain resistance, which can add up over time.

If you’re considering countertops as part of a full kitchen renovation, it’s also worth factoring in the overall cost. For example, installing an IKEA kitchen can be a budget-friendly option, with costs ranging from $8,000 to $15,000, depending on the size and materials chosen. This range of styles and designs can complement both quartz and granite countertops.

By planning your budget carefully, you can balance the upfront costs of materials with long-term durability and maintenance requirements.

In terms of installation

Quartz countertops are engineered surfaces, typically lighter than granite, making them slightly easier to handle during installation. They’re pre-manufactured to exact dimensions, which can streamline the fitting process. 

Granite countertops are heavier and more challenging to fit, often requiring additional structural support for cabinets to handle their weight. As a natural material, granite may need more on-site adjustments to accommodate irregularities, which can extend the installation time and complexity.

Both materials must be installed by professionals to ensure a seamless finish and to avoid costly mistakes. Be sure to include this in your kitchen renovation checklist when planning your upgrade.

Level up your kitchen with Airtasker

Your decision to install quartz or granite countertops is a significant investment, but professional installation ensures that investment is worthwhile. Expertly installed countertops not only enhance the aesthetic appeal of your kitchen but also ensure lasting durability and functionality.

With Airtasker, you can connect with experienced kitchen renovation contractors who specialise in handling both granite and quartz countertops. These experts understand the specific requirements of each material, giving you peace of mind that your countertops are installed professionally. 

Post a task on Airtasker today! With the right help, your dream kitchen is closer than you think.