Impact driver vs drill: Which tool do you need for your project?

Are you thinking about upgrading your home? Whether installing new shelves, installing cabinets, or building a deck, having an impact driver and a drill is crucial. 

In this impact driver vs drill guide, we’ll help you understand the differences between these power tools so you can choose the right one for your home improvement projects.

What is an impact driver?

An impact driver is a power tool used for driving screws or bolts and other fasteners to rigid materials like hardwood, metals, and composites. It’s ideal for construction, automotive, and home improvement projects, as it makes screw driving and fastening hardware easier by simply twisting and hammering the screw to push it into the construction material.

Some confuse an impact driver with an impact wrench or impact gun because both tools utilise a hammering action to drive screws and fasteners. However, between impact drivers vs impact guns, the latter uses more power and force in driving screws and fasteners. 

What is a drill?

A drill driver is a versatile power tool with a dual purpose — it drills holes and drives screws. Its drill chuck (the metal device to hold the drill bit or the cutting tool) can hold different drill bits, so you may use a drill driver to bore holes in various construction materials like wood, metal, and plastic. 

Another advantage of a drill driver is its adjustable torque with variable speed settings. Torque is the twisting power that a drill or an impact driver applies to turn the screws and bolts in place. With an adjustable torque, the likelihood of damaging the screw or the construction material is reduced. 

Drill vs impact driver: What are their key differences?

Understanding the differences between an impact driver and a drill is vital to avoid using the wrong tool and prevent structural damage. Remember that although both handyman tools have a similar function, which is to drive screws, each has different applications and features. 

In terms of torque and rotational speed

Drills have a lower but more consistent torque output and rotational speed than impact drivers. This can be advantageous for projects requiring precise hole placement and size, including drilling pilot holes to prevent the screw from cracking or splitting. 

Impact drivers have higher torque than drills due to having an anvil and a hammer. The anvil is one of the internal components of an impact driver responsible for delivering a high torque. Meanwhile, the hammer works to strike the anvil, generating short, powerful bursts. 

The durable impact bits for impact drivers are another reason the tool can deliver a high torque output. This lets you to directly drive a fastener into the construction material without pre-drilling holes. 

However, an impact driver works a bit slower than a drill in terms of rotational speed. It generates a pulsing action instead of a consistent rotational speed, causing a slight pause when driving a fastener. 

In terms of size and weight

Since driver drills are versatile power tools that can handle various assembling and building tasks, they’re generally larger and heavier than impact drivers. Usually, you should use two hands when operating a drill. 

In contrast, impact drivers have a more compact and lightweight design. Their internal components consist of an anvil and hammer, which are smaller than the gearing parts of a drill. 

Due to the impact driver having a smaller and lighter design, you may use it with just one hand. This can be advantageous when driving screws while working on a ladder or in confined and cramped areas. 

In terms of noise and vibration

Are you worried about disturbing the neighbours while assembling furniture or renovating your house? Refrain from using impact drivers. These power tools are described as rattlers because they produce loud and clicking noises. 

But on the flip side, most impact drivers have a vibration-minimised feature. So, even though these tools can be very noisy, you’ll still find them comfortable to use during extended applications. 

On the other hand, drills are quieter than impact drivers. Although their motor and gearbox make slight noises, they’re generally more tolerable and less disruptive than the rattling noise that impact drivers generate. 

Regarding vibrations, drills produce minimal vibrations, exhibiting a smoother operation. Unlike impact drivers, drills don’t generate a hammering action. 

In terms of safety features

Both impact drivers and drills are safe to use. Impact drivers are small and light, giving users more control and reducing the risk of accidental slips and falls. In addition, an impact driver applies rotational force in quick, repeated pulses instead of a continuously steady force, preventing sudden and violent kickbacks. 

Meanwhile, drills have adjustable torque settings. You can use this to reduce the drill’s twisting force, making it more comfortable and less straining on the wrists. In addition, most drills come with a safety auxiliary handle, which helps provide more balance and control to the user. 

Although both power tools have several safety features, they can pose risks since drills and impact drivers use sharp drill bits. They also require electric power to work, so practise caution when working with electrical equipment. Instead of resorting to DIY, you can leave the task to an experienced handyperson.

In terms of assembly projects

Impact drivers are best for heavy-duty, repetitive screw-driving tasks such as assembling and disassembling furniture, and building sheds. They use a hexagonal shank bit (the non-cutting end of the drill bit that attaches to the chuck of the impact driver), allowing users to remove and change the drill bit quickly. 

Conversely, drills are equipped with a three-jaw chuck for bit retention, accommodating various drill bits of different shapes and sizes. This makes drills ideal for lighter and more precise tasks, including home repairs, DIY projects, and mounting fixtures.

In terms of cost

Impact drivers are more expensive than standard drills because they have higher torque and specialised mechanisms. For reference, the price range for impact drivers in Australia is $99 - £4,500.

Drills are more affordable, so these power tools are best for basic home improvement tasks. However, their prices vary greatly, with basic models priced at around $35, while the more expensive options built for heavy-duty work are priced at around $1,400. 

Professional help is also needed when handling complex building and assembling projects, so consider the cost of hiring an expert handyperson near you. 

Streamline your DIY projects with Airtasker

While impact drivers and drills are great for DIY projects, some tasks, like building a deck or patio or upgrading kitchen cabinets, might need expert help. 

Hiring a skilled handyperson from Airtasker for complex jobs can ensure everything is done safely and to a high standard. Don’t hesitate to get the extra help you need for the best results.